| Cardington-Lincoln | Madison Plains | ||
| 1 | Bishop Ready | 1 | Africentric Early College |
| 2 | Cardington-Lincoln | 2 | Amanda-Clearcreek |
| 3 | Centerburg | 3 | Bishop Hartley |
| 4 | Delaware Christian School | 4 | Bloom-Carroll |
| 5 | Elgin | 5 | Columbus Academy |
| 6 | Liberty Union | 6 | Danville |
| 7 | Mount Gilead | 7 | East Knox |
| 8 | Newark Catholic | 8 | Fredericktown |
| 9 | Northmor | 9 | Grandview Heights |
| 10 | Northridge | 10 | Heath |
| 11 | Pleasant | 11 | Johnstown-Monroe |
| 12 | Coshocton | 12 | Madison Plains |
| 13 | Garaway | 13 | North Union |
| 14 | Ridgewood | 14 | West Jefferson |
| 15 | Newcomerstown | ||